Menu of Hicksville Sweet Shop in Hicksville, New York, USA

Menu Overview

At the heart of Hicksville, New York, nestled at 75 S Broadway #46, lies a true culinary gem—Hicksville Sweet Shop. This venerable ice cream shop and diner has stood as a beacon of enduring quality and comfort for over seventy years. Its reputation is built not just on longevity but on a consistent, heartfelt dedication to simple, hearty food made with care.

The menu highlights offer a nostalgic yet satisfying journey through American breakfast and lunch classics. The Western Omelet Breakfast Plate is a standout—generous in size, fresh, and cooked to perfection, capturing the homestyle essence of a well-made diner favorite. The Blueberry Pancakes and Sausage, alongside the Short Stack with Bacon, carry that perfect balance of fluffy, moist texture and crispy, savory bacon. These dishes are more than meals; they are a warm, welcoming hug on a plate.

Equally notable is the Corned Beef Hash, a classic rendition that, while not universally loved by every guest, stands as a testament to authentic comfort food. The French Toast and Bacon Cheeseburger with Fries round out the hearty, diner-style experience. For those seeking sweetness, the Chocolate Malt Shake is a creamy indulgence, a perfect counterpoint to the savory items.

Beyond breakfast and lunch staples, Hicksville Sweet Shop’s menu intriguingly features a variety of wraps—including Chicken, Tuna, Greek, Spinach, Gyro, and Rueben options—that add a lighter, refreshing dimension to their offerings. The Diet Delights section, showcasing scoops of chicken or tuna salad on lettuce, caters well to those seeking a healthier touch.

Their scrumptious sundaes such as the Banana Royale, Clover Leaf, Hot Fudge, Hicksville Special, Strawberry, and Walnut embody the shop’s old-school charm and commitment to homemade goodness. These treats, alongside the seasonal homemade chocolates, are a must-try. They’re fleeting treasures, often sold out early, which adds a sense of urgency and delight when available.

What sets Hicksville Sweet Shop apart is not just the food, but the experience—friendly, capable staff, and a spotless diner atmosphere. The owner’s occasional presence on a classic dial phone behind the register evokes a comforting sense of timeless tradition. Regulars cherish the specials board, where dishes like the Athenian and the stroganoff offer a cozy, satisfying alternative—true comfort food that disappears quickly.

From reviews by loyal patrons like Creek Johnson, who praises the shop as a surviving piece of Long Island history, to locals like Tom S and Nick May who appreciate the steady quality and value, Hicksville Sweet Shop clearly holds a special place in the community. Kimberly Rodriguez’s note on the affordability and generous portions confirms that here, quality never comes at an extravagant price.

In essence, Hicksville Sweet Shop is more than just an ice cream and breakfast joint—it is a culinary time capsule where you can savor hearty breakfasts, classic lunches, and delightful desserts in an unpretentious setting. Whether you’re stepping in after visiting nearby landmarks like IKEA or Jones Beach or simply seeking a reliable, comforting meal, this shop promises consistency, warmth, and a taste of tradition.