Discover Hicksville Sweet Shop, your go-to destination for scrumptious sundaes, homemade ice cream, and delicious diner-style wraps. Located in the heart of Hicksville, this classic eatery offers a nostalgic atmosphere, friendly service, and unbeatable va
Service: Offers takeaway / Serves dine-in / No delivery / No same-day delivery
Hicksville Sweet Shop, nestled at 75 S Broadway #46 in the heart of Hicksville, NY, is more than just an ice cream shop—it’s a cherished local institution. With over seventy years standing strong, this diner-style eatery embodies the timeless spirit of Long Island’s culinary heritage. Its unpretentious space, spotless and inviting, reflects the care and tradition that permeate every aspect of the experience.
The menu leans into classic comfort with a curated selection emphasizing quality over quantity. Staples like the Western Omelet Breakfast Plate, Blueberry Pancakes accompanied by ample sausage, and the Short Stack with Bacon showcase the kitchen’s ability to deliver hearty, satisfying meals with simple, fresh ingredients. The Corn Beef Hash and French Toast also prove popular for those seeking nostalgic flavors. For a savory twist, their Bacon Cheeseburger paired with fries hits the mark, balancing diner favorites with homey execution.
What truly sets Hicksville Sweet Shop apart is its seamless fusion of breakfast and sweet delights. Beyond meals, the array of homemade ice cream flavors such as Maple Walnut, Peach, Banana, Butter Pecan, and Coffee offer a rich, creamy finish that resonates with longtime patrons and newcomers alike. The fountain drinks, including thick shakes and classics like Root Beer and Hot Cocoa, add an old-school charm.
Regulars cherish not only the food but the atmosphere—a friendly, almost familial vibe, where the owner might still be heard on the vintage dial phone, managing pick-up orders with care. The specials board beckons those in the know, with dishes like the Athenian or stroganoff offering comforting, rotating selections that elevate the everyday diner experience. And for a grand finish, the waffle sundae with homemade ice cream and whipped cream, occasionally topped with honey from the owner’s own hives, presents a sweet testament to the shop’s dedication to homemade quality.
Ideal for families, locals, or visitors fresh off the nearby Hicksville train station, the Sweet Shop caters to anyone craving genuine, no-frills breakfast and lunch fare. The honest, straightforward approach coupled with attentive service and a welcoming environment makes it a rare find amid today’s rapidly changing food landscape. Whether it’s a quick breakfast, a leisurely lunch, or a nostalgic treat after visiting area landmarks, Hicksville Sweet Shop stands as a reliable destination where good food and tradition endure.
